Weather Updates

Right-to-work myths

Rifles foreground handguns are displayed for gun show participants MariettGa. Saturday Dec. 22 2012. As gun control talks heup Washingtmore

Rifles, foreground, and handguns are displayed for gun show participants in Marietta, Ga. on Saturday, Dec. 22, 2012. As gun control talks heat up in Washington, more than 1,000 people lined up Saturday morning outside the exhibit hall at Jim Miller Park in Cobb County for the Eastman Gun Show. (AP Photo/Mike Stewart)

storyidforme: 42134553
tmspicid: 15580325
fileheaderid: 7027216

Updated: January 27, 2013 6:20AM

Right-to-work myths

Bruce Rauner’s recent commentary [“Illinois next stop for labor reform,” Dec. 21] adds little to the debate about how labor law reform could attract new businesses and jobs to Illinois.

Research shows that there is no connection between so-called right-to-work laws and business location decisions. In fact, business location decisions tend to focus on transportation needs and an educated and trained work force. Indiana is quickly learning what Oklahoma — the last state to pass such a law in 2001 — found: states are more likely to lose jobs because the real effect of right to work is to depress wages and weaken insurance and retirement benefits.

What such research does show is that businesses locate where they have access to the most skilled workers, and can rely on modern transportation, utility and energy infrastructure. Education plays a huge role, but what schools can’t provide in training is picked up by the apprenticeship and training programs administered jointly by management and labor. Free collective bargaining between employers and unions is the national labor policy because labor and management are often in the best position to come up with real solutions to real problems.

Today, for example, the Indiana, Illinois and Iowa Foundation for Fair Contracting — a labor-management group dedicated to promoting the construction industry in those states — is working to develop a collectively bargained alternative to the Illinois workers’ compensation system.

Rather than punishing union workers by forcing them to shoulder the cost of representing free-riders with backward looking right-to-work laws, Illinois lawmakers should encourage such private-sector innovation, and focus on real reform.

Marc Poulos,

Indiana, Illinois and Iowa Foundation For Fair Contracting

No Real Accountability

NRA . . . No Real Accountability. The NRA’s effort to offer help with America’s gun problem is akin to the Wild Wild West, a six shooter and holster for everyone. True leadership would have called for ways to take guns off the streets and out of the hands of those who would harm themselves or others.

Terry O’Dowd, Naperville

© 2014 Sun-Times Media, LLC. All rights reserved. This material may not be copied or distributed without permission. For more information about reprints and permissions, visit To order a reprint of this article, click here.