Weather Updates

Sheriff, police reopen murder case that saw ‘Dixmoor 5’ wrongly convicted

Updated: May 7, 2014 6:10PM

Dixmoor police are reopening the case of a 14-year-old girl killed in 1991 and will get help this time from the Cook County Sheriff’s Office, officials announced Wednesday.

Five teenagers were charged and convicted in the slaying of Cateresa Matthews, but the last of them was released from prison in 2011 after DNA evidence excluded them. The so-called “Dixmoor Five” served between them served between 10 and 19 years in prison. Three were later granted certificates of innocence by the state.

Federal lawsuits filed in 2012 by the five claimed that Dixmoor and Illinois State Police knew the DNA evidence excluded them but that officers coerced confessions out of them anyway. The suit, which is still pending, also alleged that police linked the DNA to a sex offender who had been released on parole shortly before the murder.

That person, who has been in and out of prison for other offenses, has never been charged in the Matthews case.

Sheriff Tom Dart — who has a history of investigating cold cases, such as that of John Wayne Gacy — said he got involved after Dixmoor Police Chief Ron Burge appealed to him for help. His office had not previously investigated the case.

Dart would not address specifics of the case or the DNA but said his team, with Dixmoor Police, would be re-investigating all aspects of the case.

“We are collectively going to be working to bring justice to Cateresa Matthews and her family,” Dart said.

Burge, a former Dolton police chief who was appointed Dixmoor chief in January, said he grew up next to Matthews’ mother and knew the girl personally.

“I saw her grow up, so this is somewhat personal. I reached out to the Sheriff’s Office because they have the capability and manpower” to investigate a “case of this magnitude.”

Contributing: Kim Janssen


Twitter: @artgolab

© 2014 Sun-Times Media, LLC. All rights reserved. This material may not be copied or distributed without permission. For more information about reprints and permissions, visit To order a reprint of this article, click here.